Skip to content
Luck Digest

I Dived Into Pokémon FireRed As If It Were 2026 and Wound Up Losing All My Progress Due to My Mistake.

Similar to how my barely legible teenage penmanship has devolved through decades of digital document creation, my instincts to halt and record progress in a game diminished. I attribute this to the advent of automatic saving, save points, Xbox Quick Resume, and titles where the tension is so high that I feel compelled to save constantly just in case disaster strikes. However, I am human. I get lazy. Recently, I discovered a vital reminder eight hours into the newly ported Pokémon FireRed for Nintendo Switch: you still gotta smash that save button.

It had been years since I picked up a classic Pokémon title — having missed the boat on the GBA era, the Johto region games probably were the last mainline Poké-title I completed. Consequently, I was thrilled to spend $19.99 for a trip down memory lane to the Kanto region, and a quest gathering those first 151 creatures. I was instantly transported to my youth. During a handful of gaming sessions, I captured Bug-types, added Pikachu to my team, beat Brock on my first turn, gambled on buying the Magikarp from the Man at the Pokémon Center, and scaled Mt. Moon without a worry in the world.

The fatal flaw: Not once did I save! The idea simply didn't occur to me.

That Jigglypuff shall never find love with my Mankey.

Disaster struck during a session while I was taking a break from the game… and as my daughter took the console for a quick half-hour of the latest game in its place, quitting my application as a result. As we all know (as I should have known…) starting another application on the console closes the active game. Your progress is only safe if the game autosaved or if you remembered to save prior to changing games. Whoops.

The Progression of Save Systems: From Manual to Automatic

We should regard automatic saving, now so effortless most players barely notice it, as a true “next-generation” breakthrough. Although the classic text game Zork implemented a pioneering save functions in a game, the 1986 Zelda title is often credited as a milestone moment for alleviating the sensation of being utterly defeated by an in-game fail thanks to cartridge-based saving on NES cartridges. Naturally, the responsibility remained to save. (And after one flub), the lesson was learned for life. Through the 1990s, save cards for systems like PlayStation normalized the save process though they were still vulnerable; failing to save (or losing a card) could wipe hours of progress. The survival horror series Resident Evil went so far as to make saving into a limited resource.

Contemporary background saving, the one that subdued my natural saving reflex my retro gaming session so effectively, gained prominence at the dawn of a new century. The original Halo introduced checkpoint saving while Call of Duty refined the system to streamline challenge and eliminate repetition. As the play grew longer — and increasingly non-linear — devs cracked the code on constant background saves and, eventually, the ultimate convenience of picking up exactly where you left off.

A Franchise's Adaptation: From Deliberate Action to Automatic Assurance

Funny enough, the Pokémon series is a great reflection of that technological evolution. For years, preserving your Pokédex progress was a deliberate choice: gamers were conditioned to hit “Save” ahead of powering down their handheld console. Starting with Pokémon Sword and Shield on Switch, Game Freak implemented an autosave feature (initially optional), representing a substantial design shift for a franchise known as most tradition-bound franchises.

I own up to my blunder: A long tenure with Breath of the Wild and contemporary Nintendo titles completely dulled my manual save reflex. I still know better in some cases — I wouldn't dare risk quitting during a run in a challenging indie title despite being aware it saves progress automatically — however, perhaps due to my extended absence from into a retro-style game, or I'm simply pampered, the thought never entered my mind to manually save before redocking. My younger self would never have fumbled this badly.

The Result: A Discouraged Player

I have not opened FireRed following the great progress wipe. When I loaded it back up and discovered my team consisted solely of my starter Squirtle, a wave of exhaustion hit me. The verdict: Burned.

Maybe I’ll go back… or perhaps I'll remain in the hundreds of new games available now that kindly assume I need my hand held. However, my fondness for older titles remains alive. During times I can distract my kid to pause the modern, auto-saving Pokémon game, we have been cooperatively playing Switch 2’s Super Bomberman Collection. Those classic titles skipped saving altogether in favor of cryptic character strings. Therefore, if I make a fatal mistake, the setback is minimal. That, at least, is reassuring.

Written by

Judy Clark

A philosopher and statistician who writes about the intersection of luck, probability, and human experience, with a background in behavioral science.

Luck Digest

Type to search articles.